All-Ohio Bobcats

 Ed Hare  1965,1966 Basketball
 Jeff Hall  1974 Baseball
 Brian Duff  1982 Wrestling
 Tommy “Tank” Moore  1988 Wrestling
 Eddie Nicholson  1990 Cross Country
 Louise Oess  1990 Basketball & Volleyball
 Jeff Bentz  1993 Football
 Phil Conrath  1993 Cross Country
 Bridget Mitchell  1993 Softball
 Jeremy Wilkinson  1993 Wrestling
 Geno Ford  1992,1993 Basketball
 1993 Mr. Basketball
 Jesse Wilkin  1994 Golf
 Stephanie Gotschall  1995 Swimming
 T.J. King  1995,1996 Wrestling
 Joey Ross  1999 Track
 Shannon Funk  1999 Swimming
 Ben Suitt  1999,2000 Academic – Track
 2000 Track
 Ashley Hollins  1999,2001 Track (High Jump)
 Ashley Dunigan  1999 Cross Country
 2002 Track (16M State Champion)
 2000,2001,2002 Academic – Cross Country & Track
 Adam Davenport  2000,2001 Basketball
 2001 Track (Shot Put)
 Michael Price  2001,2002 Wrestling (Heavyweight 5th)
 Brandon Todd  2002,2003 Basketball
 Clifford Clark IV  2013 Football
 Rylee Rogers  2012 Baseball
 Sawyer Leppla  2012 Wrestling (5th)
 Dashaun Lewis  2011 Football
 Caleb Gunn  2010 Football
 Andrew Bertubin  2009,2010 Wrestling (State Runner Up, 6th)
 Katie Davis  2009 Track (High Jump – Champion)
 Thomas Norris  2009 Track (Long Jump – 6th)
 Dillon VanDyne  2009 Wrestling (7th)
 Chad Teague  2008 Wrestling
 Sarah Starr  2008 Softball
 Paul Rose  2006,2007,2008 Wrestling
 John Nicolozakes  2006 Wrestling
 Dustin Daugherty  2006 Wrestling
 Stephen Ford  2006 Football
 Brad Wright  2003,2004 Golf
 Jessica Lynn  2003 Track
 Yvonne Hamilton  2001 Track (4×100)
 Victoria Hamilton
 Natalee Noche
 Kristin Spencer
 Kristen Funk  2001 Swimming
 Charlie Ford  1985 Football
 Eric Fox  2012,2013,2014 Track (Pole Vault – 4th, 2nd, 2nd)
 2014 Football
 Ivan Gadson  2014 Track (100m Dash – 6th)
 Errik Snell  2013,2014,2015 Track (110m Hurdles – 2nd,1st,4th)
 Stephanie Massey  2015 Track (Shot Put – 3rd)
 Lilly Ritz  2017,2018 Basketball
 2015,2016,2017,2018 Track (High Jump – 5th,4th,2nd,5th)